Woe to the rich?

My clergy colleague the Rev. Mark Lycos shared a story in a recent sermon that resonated with me. It comes from surgeon general Dr. Vivek Murthy’s 2020 book Together: the Healing Power of Human Connection in a Sometimes Lonely World. In his book, Dr. Murthy tells the story of a patient named James who came to him with various common health concerns including diabetes and high blood pressure. But what was remarkable was what James told Dr. Murthy during his examination. He said, “Winning the lottery was one of the worst things that ever happened to me.” How could that be? Don’t we all believe our lives would be better if we had lots of money. But clearly this man had come to realize that his health had been damage by that so-called “lucky” turn of events. You see, prior to winning the lottery, James had been a baker. He loved his work and enjoyed the companionship of his co-workers. After winning the lottery, he retired and moved to a big house in a secluded neighborhood where people kept to themselves. He ate whatever he wanted, gained weight, and developed diabetes. His isoloation led to depression, and he soon found himself taking a long list of medications. Dr. Murthy realized that his main illness was loneliness. We’ve long known that a lack of social connections is bad for your emotional and mental health, but now medicine is learning that it’s bad for your physical health, too. Many even say we’re facing a loneliness epidemic, which has only been made worse by the Covid pandemic. 


We know that some of this epidemic is the result of our highly technological age. As is so often the case, technology is a mixed blessing. It empowers us and even connects us across great distances. I was on a few Zoom meetings this week with people in distant cities. In fact, Martha Bains joined the Wednesday Rector’s Bible Study from London. How cool is that? We were having our morning coffee, but since it was 4:00 or 5:00 in the afternoon there, I suggested she go pour herself a Scotch. She reminded me that their trip was sponsored by Samford- no Scotch allowed in the house.  Of course, in other ways technology isolates us. Whereas in the past, I might have borrowed a tool from a neighbor and chatted for a while face to face, these days I’m more likely to make a few click on Amazon and have sent to my doorstep with no human contact.


We don’t have to be lottery winners to discover that our abundance of material things comes at a cost. Possessions and wealth have a way of separating us from others and isolating us. Though he lived in a much simpler time, Jesus knew this to be true. His teaching was countercultural, even shocking, to those who gathered to listen to him that day. “Blessed are you who are poor, for yours is the Kingdom of Heaven. But woe to you who are rich, for you have received your consolation.”


This passage is often called the Sermon on the Plain as opposed to the Sermon on the Mount, which we find in the Gospel of Matthew because it begins with Luke telling us that Jesus came down and stood on a level place. And the location of the speech is not the only difference. Here Jesus doesn’t say blessed are the poor in spirit, he says blessed are the poor. He doesn’t say blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness. He says blessed are those who are hungry now. You might say that the Sermon on the Plain is more down to earth. Jesus is addressing those who are suffering in this world and at this moment.


Unlike Matthew, Luke also includes a list of woes addressed to those who are happy by worldly standards, those whose lives are marked by wealth, full bellies, laughter, and admirers. The woes emphasize the surprising reversals we discover in God’s Kingdom. It turns out that what God values is usually very different from what the world values. As we continue reading from the Sermon on the Plain next Sunday, we’ll hear Jesus proclaim some of his most famous and yet most difficult teachings: “Love your enemies. Bless those who curse you. Turn the other cheek. Judge not, lest ye be judged.” And the Golden Rule: “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” Followers of Christ have been struggling with these teachings from the beginning. 


Though we are all perhaps rich by Jesus’ standards, I know that even members of this congregation have experienced poverty and food insecurity at some point in their lives. And all of us have wept with grief at some point in our lives. When you are going through hard times, you sure don’t feel blessed. And yet, sometime we look back on our struggles and realize there was a strange gift hidden in the middle of them. So I think there are two basic ways to look at the beatitudes. We can view them as wisdom for this life, and we can view them as wisdom for the life to come, that is, life in the Kingdom of God.


So from the perspective of ordinary life in this world, how is it that the poor, hungry, and persecuted are blessed, while the rich and powerful will suffer woe? First, Jesus is reminding us that life is transitory. Whatever our circumstances are now, things will change. Kind of like the weather in Alabama. If all is going well, you’ve got nowhere to go but down. And when you’ve hit the bottom, you’ve got nowhere to go but up. Furthermore, when everything is going well, it is easy to become isolated and desensitized to the needs of others. You don’t really need other people. It’s possible to move from being self-sufficient to being self-satisfied and self-centered.  And that is recipe for unhappiness.


But when we live humbly, trusting God to provide what we really need, when we are willing to work hard and make sacrifices, when we treat others with kindness and are generous with our resources, when we are grateful for what we have, and not always comparing ourselves to those who have more, then we discover what it means to be happy.


It’s not that the rich are inherently bad or the poor inherently good. It’s just that when you have less, you can’t pretend you have no need of others. What matters is what’s in a person’s heart. What matters is what we make of the situation we find ourselves in. Do we add to the world’s misery or do we lessen it. Do we bring joy to others? Or do we get joy at the expense of others?


And so there is value in this world in following the teaching of Jesus. Yes, we will suffer for it, but then again, no life is free from suffering. No, not even the rich and famous get through life without struggles.  If anything, their problems just get bigger. The reality is that life is bittersweet. There are joys and sorrows for all of us. The question is how do we find meaning in our joys and sorrows? And do those joys and sorrows lead us closer to God or further from God?


And that’s why these difficult teachings of Jesus are not just about making the world a better place here and now. As Paul, writes to the Corinthians, “If for this life only we have hoped in Christ, then we are of all people most to be pitied.” Jesus’ teaching has an eternal dimension. The beatitudes are about life in the Kingdom of God, a kingdom that is both a present reality and yet not fully realized. In the scope of eternity, our lives are but a mist that appears for a little while and then vanishes, as the Book of James puts it (James 4:14). That doesn’t mean poverty, hunger, grief, and persecution inconsequential. It doesn’t mean we don’t have an obligation to relieve the suffering of our fellow human beings. What it means is that nothing is lost or wasted in God’s economy. Every tear that fall from our eyes is treasured by God. More than that, if we truly believe in an incarnate God, then we can say that God cries with us. And God will redeem our tears of grief with tears of joy.


Christ invites us to get to know our own poverty, our own hunger, our own sorrow and persecution, not so that we can wallow in self-pity, but so that we might grow in compassion for others. If we only see ourselves as more fortunate than others, we may fail to see the blessings that the poor have to give to us. In God’s kingdom all the children are beloved. And all the children have something to share.  In God’s Kingdom we have all we need in abundance.


The key to understanding the beatitudes is recognizing that the one who was crucified in weakness was raised in glory.  Each one of those “blessed are you’s” is followed by a promise. When we see life through the lens of Christ’s death and resurrection, then these seemingly illogical values make perfect sense. We begin to see that the kingdom that Jesus proclaims is not some far off place and time, but right here in the midst of us. But to see it requires a shift in how we look at the world. It challenges us to look beyond the grave to a resurrected life and to live as resurrected people here and now.



More Announcements

September 12, 2025
This fall, we invite you to join us for Faith & The Modern Family , an engaging series that takes a fresh look at the intersection of faith and family in today’s world. Each week, a different speaker will lead discussion on timely and relevant topics designed to help us grow in faith together. The series runs from September 14 through December 14 in Room 223, in between services .  Here’s the schedule of upcoming sessions: Sept 14 – The Rev. Ranie Neislar Sept 21 – Josh Reeves Sept 28 – The Rev. Ed Bacon Oct 5 – Emily Holm Oct 12 – The Rev. Ranie Neislar Oct 19 – Josh Reeves Oct 26 – Drew Hataway Nov 2 – No Class Nov 9 – David Smith Nov 16 – Chris Couch Nov 23 – No Class Nov 30 – Susanna Whitsett Dec 7 – The Rev. Kelley Hudlow Dec 14 – Memily Colvin Drop in anytime, each week features a new topic, so you can come when it works for you. For more details, contact the Rev. Ranie Neislar at rneislar@allsaintsbhm.org .
September 9, 2025
This fall, gather with us for Wonder-Full Wednesdays. Each week brings something different—game night, pet blessings, trunk-or-treat, a chili cook-off, caroling, and more. Share dinner, enjoy the company, and connect with community in meaningful ways. September 17 Game Night on the Lawn October 1 Pet Blessing Chick-fil-A dinner. Bring your furry, shelled, or scaly pet to be blessed. October 29 Trunk or Treat Pizza & Hot Dog dinner, come dressed to get those treat. November 12 Chili Cook-Off Chili dinner. Taste and judge some of the finest chili in the land. November 19 Service & gratitude Night Thanksgiving Dinner. Help us pack meals for those in need. December 3 Advent Festival Spaghetti Dinner. Prepping for Advent with things crafty and cool. December 10 St. Nick at Night Pizza Dinner. Come be a part of the story of St. Nick. December 17 Caroling in the Neighborhood Chick-fil-A dinner. Sing your favorite carols with a hot cup of cocoa.
A choir bbq is postponed until sept 22 due to rain
By choir bbq September 5, 2025
The Choir BBQ is Sunday, September 21! Join us in the Great Hall for lunch following the 11:00 service. The Adult Choir will be serving bbq pork, buns, baked beans, slaw, brownies, and lemonade. Hot dogs will be available for kids. To-go plates are available after both the 8:30am and 11:00am services. Whole butts $45 Order by 9/17; quantities are limited, so order early to make sure you get one! Family Meals for 4 $35 Order by 9/17 Individual Plates $10 Eat-in or to-go; no reservation required Contact Melanie Couch at mcouch@allsaintsbhm.org with any questions. All proceeds will benefit the Adult Choir music ministry. Thanks for your support!
September 2, 2025
Game Night on the Lawn – September 17 ! Starts at 5:30pm with pizza dinner, lawn games, and plenty of fun. A relaxed evening on the lawn with food, games, and fun for all ages.
August 28, 2025
What a summer it’s been for Fiddlesticks Music! From late May until now, we’ve been singing, dancing, and drumming our way across Birmingham, bringing people together from all walks of life into one joyful circle of music. Every time we sing with children, we’re shining the light of Christ in our community, breaking down barriers and building connections among families of many different stories, cultures, and resources. This summer alone, we’ve touched hundreds of lives through the power of music. Highlights from the season: In May, our Fiddlesticks Family Sing-along Concert filled the Great Hall with over 70 voices, young and old, singing in harmony. In June, we celebrated the National Day of Making at the McWane Science Center by making music together and helping little ones craft their own instruments. We returned to McWane to mark the 10th Anniversary of Itty Bitty Magic City with joyful songs and play. At the Birmingham Folk Festival, our classes at the Avondale Library had children and caregivers singing and moving together all afternoon. We brought free demo classes to the Homewood Library, introducing even more families to the joy of Music Together®. And all spring, we partnered with UAB Head Start, bringing music-making to families who might not otherwise have that opportunity. At Fiddlesticks Music Together®, we provide weekly 45-minute classes for children from infancy through age eight, following a research-based curriculum designed to nurture musical growth and create meaningful connections. But our calling is much bigger than that. Our doors are open to families of all identities, abilities, and ages—because music, and the love that pours out through All Saints, is for everyone. Fall Registration Registration is open for FALL Session 2025! The 11-week fall session is September 7 - November 22 . These Fiddlesticks Music classes are perfect for infants to 5-year olds and their "grown-ups." Parents, grandparents, or nannies come make music with your little one through singing, dancing, and musical play! When you register, make sure to let us know that you are a member at All Saints, to receive 20% off of the $195 tuition. We also have need-based scholarship options. Learn more or to register for the session today: www.fiddlesticks-music.com .
August 26, 2025
Have you ever wondered where your gifts might be leading you? This survey is designed to help you reflect on your strengths and how they might be used in meaningful ways. This will give you insights into areas where your talents and passions may align with opportunities to serve.  Once you’ve finished, we’ll receive your results and reach out to you to talk more about what they reveal.
Show More